American Idiot @ Mayflower Theatre, Southampton

When, way back in 2004, Green Day released American Idiot it was a clarion call for the disaffected youth of the US. It leapt up the charts on a wave of critical acclaim and commercial success and was much beloved of a certain callow young music blogger in provincial Portsmouth. Fast forward 15 years and I don’t perhaps listen to the album very often now but it still holds significance as it’s first theatrical incarnation was one of the first theatre pieces I reviewed and quite probably the point that convinced me to start this site. Now, a good few years later here I am again in Southampton for the launch of a new national tour.

This new production from Selladoor is as brash, raucous and punchy as you might expect and opens with all guns blazing into the title song. The cast leap about the stage; singing, pogo-ing, giving the number all the attitude they can and playing synchronised air guitar to the classic riff of the song. It’s an energetic all-action display but it suffers from an underlying issue… you can’t choreograph anarchy!

It’s true elsewhere too, the heartfelt moments shine but the more choreographed the song the less the impact of the message. The endless “look at us we’re outsiders” swagger is incredibly grating and the default response of every character to flip off the audience, each other and anything around them at any available opportunity makes their extended middle fingers about as shocking and rebellious as Susan Boyle.

For all that though, there is a lot to enjoy here, when the band are in full swing they’re excellent and anyone who has found themselves dripping with sweat in a dingy bar or venue listening to local rock and punk acts will be glad to see these guys are the real deal with the tattoos and dress sense to show for it.

When the tempo drops you get to glimpse some really good performances too. Tom Milner makes for a frenetic Johnny and his constant knowing looks to the audience were much appreciated by the young ladies sat in front of me. It’s no fault of his but Johnny’s letters home to his mother feel like a cheap copy of Mark’s straight to audience diary notes from RENT and a potentially powerful scene of him shooting up heroin is lost because a large chunk of the audience can’t see what is happening.

Joshua Dowen shines as Tunny, the slacker who joins the army to find himself and the morphine fuelled Extraordinary Girl is a real highlight. Samuel Pope is excellent as Will, the friend who is left behind and his interaction with Siobhan O Driscoll’s Heather is where the show really shows its heart!

Ultimately this is a strange beast, as likely to frustrate musical theatre enthusiasts as it is to annoy long time Green Day fans. If you want some cracking tunes and a few really good performances though you’ll find something to enjoy here.

until 26th January in Southampton and then heading out on tour. Go to for more info.



Matt has been writing on all manner of subjects for over 15 years. He has written for a number of music magazines, made appearances on BBC Introducing and regularly contributed to local newspapers. These days he mostly writes about theatre, but also enjoys covering sport, especially rugby.

One thought on “American Idiot @ Mayflower Theatre, Southampton

  1. I agree! There were definitely some heartfelt moments, and there was a lot of fun, but the “anarchy” was not very anarchic.

    I did find the heroin scene difficult to watch, but I think that’s props to the actors really!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.